I’d the desire. A good unusual beast, human being Siamese twin babies surfaced through Bliss and also the Head of the family stated, “Behold, these were your own forefathers, probably the most well-known few actually, Adam as well as Eve”.
The actual small infants such as every other wholesome twin babies — seem sleepers — nuzzled to one another. Just following having to pay near interest you could find a couple of peculiarities. These were became a member of through their own sternum as well as their own tummies had been becoming fused. Much more remarkably one of these had been young man and also the additional infant woman. However they didn’t trouble, as well hectic in order to rest as well as pull from their own thumbs.
The actual desire and also the image busy my personal thoughts with regard to days. Very first, We had been horrified. I quickly began contemplating. It’s past likelihood, or even it’s not? Following three-month investigation brought through the Holy Nature, I’ve solid my personal concept. Indeed, it’s possible how the most well-known human being few was created because conjoined twin babies along with various genders. They ought to possess divided as well as flower very carefully till these people turn out to be prepared to grow.
And also the HEAD OF THE FAMILY Lord triggered the heavy rest in order to drop on Adam, as well as he or she rested: as well as he or she required among their ribs, as well as shut in the skin rather thereof; And also the rib, that the HEAD OF THE FAMILY Lord experienced obtained from guy, created he or she a female, as well as introduced the woman’s on to the person. As well as Adam stated, This particular [is] right now bone fragments associated with my personal bone fragments, as well as skin associated with my personal skin: your woman will be known as Lady, simply because your woman had been removed from Guy. (GENESIS 21-23, KJV)
The actual look at from the Holy bible is definitely an precise accounts associated with actual occasions may be asked through students upon numerous reasons — for instance — associated with biblical critique. These people essentially think about the Holy Publications because “figments associated with imagination” that contradicts along with just about all medical hypotheses. Promoters associated with inerrancy from the Holy bible consider the reverse placement. These people declare the actual Holy bible is actually precise as well as free from mistake as well as doesn’t agree something that is actually unlike details. The one thing that should be thought about because associated with unfolding details within the Holy bible may be the stratification from the holy textual content and also the superimposition associated with various connotations from it.
Rabbinic resources train all of us concerning the 70 encounters from the Torah. These people show there can be several various amounts of the actual meaning from the holy textual content. Nevertheless, regardless of the actual variations, they’ve been influenced through the Holy Nature therefore it signifies the truth and also the reality. Each and every passage of every guide from the Holy Bible — these people declare — offers its, historic as well as grammatical, hinted, implied as well as clever, solution or even mystic connotations. These people deal actually that each person notice from the Torah is actually holy.
Nevertheless, whenever we show up towards biblical passages involved within topics such as the development associated with Event — the thoughts avoid towards the actually meaning. All of us often be satisfied with much less as well as take this how the tale may be simple meaning designed to express as well as catalyze ethical theories. It requires huge belief to simply accept The lord’s phrases upon development associated with Event like a truth which could show clinically.
The actual Sages trained all of us too which Lord offered the various tools in order to explore what associated with Holy Scriptures as well as uncover the actual divine knowledge concealed inside them. The actual Holy Holy bible is actually The lord’s knowledge, that allows with regard to various views, however The lord’s may is actually complete as well as doesn’t permit 2 methods to check out points.
Very first query: rib or even aspect? This is from the Hebrew noun tsela.
Tsela had been converted “rib” within Genesis two: twenty one, KJV. Nevertheless, additionally, it converted aspect (19), step (11), planks (2), edges (2), supports (1), the halting of (1), simply leaves (1), cedar planks (1) within the additional passages from the Holy bible. (The amounts within the mounting brackets display all of us the number of occasions the actual provided interpretation occurs within the Holy bible. ) Decide to try be aware this is associated with “side” are available in nineteen passages from the holy textual content, the actual among the “rib” just within 2 of these. Ethan Dor-Shav authored: “In the actual holy bible the most popular term tzela usually indicates aspect or even flank, just like a aspect of the sq ., or perhaps a flank (side) from the tabernacle, the actual ark, or even the actual church. Along side it associated with something, by the creating as with: “On it’s 2 flanks upon it’s 2 sides” (Exodus thirty seven: 27). The actual biblical phrase can also be employed for the actual flank of the hill, as well as with regard to safeguarding a person’s flank within battle. However, the word is actually in no way employed for the bone fragments within the upper body, producing the actual Genesis interpretation because “rib” absolutely phony. “[i]
“This incredible report associated with the way the very first lady came to exist may be the item associated with a lot poker fun at, inch — Holly Morris, PhD creates within their post — “but it’s totally as well as actually accurate. Nevertheless, the actual “rib” that Lord utilized had been not likely the rib whatsoever. Instead, the actual Hebrew term in many associated with it’s incidences is actually converted possibly “side” or even “side step. inch This particular will be a much better interpretation right here, too. It might be which Eve’s entire body had been created through Lord through Adam’s aspect, or even through some thing inside the “chamber” associated with their aspect. inch
When compared the actual Full Wayne Edition in order to additional Holy bible translations, for instance, towards the Increased Holy bible, the actual second option enables the actual ambiguity from the term tzela.
“And god, the father Lord triggered the heavy rest in order to drop on Adam; even though he or she rested, He or she required among their ribs or even part of their aspect as well as shut in the [place with] skin. And also the rib or even a part of their aspect that the Head of the family Lord experienced obtained from the person He or she developed as well as converted to a female, as well as He or she introduced the woman’s towards the guy. inch (Genesis 21-22, AB).
The brand new Residing Interpretation inside a footnote indicates the actual interpretation “took part of the actual male’s side” rather than the “took among their ribs. inch
“We determine out of this brief evaluation that there’s absolutely no actual validation in order to make the term within Genesis two: twenty one because Adam’s rib. Instead, it ought to be Adam’s side” — David Simpson mentioned within their amazing post. [ii] Amen.
Incredible Terra Cotta Statue through Metal Grow older
A few of the very first types of advanced statue within sub-SaharanAfricacame in the Nok lifestyle, a good Metal Grow older the world. The actual lifestyle made an appearance close to 1000 W. D. as well as inexplicably disappeared close to 500 ADVERT around Western The african continent.
Within 1928 Lt-Colonel Steve Dent-Young had been top exploration procedures within the Nigerian villageof Nok. Near to the town, near the Jos Level area among their miners discovered a little bit of terra cotta statue. Later on, terra cottas spread from numerous absolute depths through the Sahelgrasslands had been unearthed. The actual statues variety in dimensions through little chains in order to life-size numbers. These days a number of components of all of them is visible in the BarakatFamilyMuseum. One of these may be worth in our unique interest, the thirty-one by sixteen cm statue of the seated few. [iii]
Memorialized within clay-based, this particular few signifies a set of conjoined, or even Siamese, twin babies that can make the actual artifact unequaled as well as breath-taking. Conjoined twin babies tend to be among the rarest types of twinning as well as would likely end up being construed like a the majority of threatening occasion anytime as well as in a neighborhood. This particular statue catches the actual vision of the organic question. Nevertheless, there’s another thing as well. This established fact which conjoined twin babies is definitely monozygotic, consequently, possibly guys or even women. Nonetheless, the actual designer symbolized 1 double because woman (with breasts) and also the additional because man (without breasts as well as that additionally seems to be higher compared to woman co-twin).
The actual sitting few reveal 1 lower-leg and therefore are linked in the body. Even though these people put on 2 bracelets within the entrance, the actual pendant seems as you within the back again. This particular beautiful statue should have privileged the the majority of magnificent as well as holy set of creatures within the historic occasions. Michael. M. MarÃÂnez FrÃÂas views the actual incredible Nok artifact like a rendering of the extremely very first recognized situation associated with conjoined twin babies along with various genders within history.
The reason why do the actual designer signify 1 double woman and also the additional man? This can’t be conjoined, monozygotic twin babies along with various genders! The unexplainable historic lifestyle — the only real logical solution may arrived at the thoughts — created the magical porcelain figurine with regard to spiritual reasons with no purpose of getting this already been attached to the truth.
However can definitely not really end up being monozygotic twin babies along with various genders?
The very first in support of documented situation associated with conjoined twin babies showing morphologically various genders
Within 2007 Ellie as well as co-workers released exactly what seems to be the very first in support of documented situation associated with conjoined twin babies, showing exterior as well as inner genitalia associated with morphologically various genders. (In revenge from the unique various lovemaking looks tiny evaluation demonstrated which inner genitalia experienced oocytes within each twin babies as well as chromosomal research recorded which each had been women (XX). )[iv]
The actual medical description of these uncommon as well as surprising phenomena requires a brief intro very first.
A few history info
Probably the most fascinating bodily flaws contained in an infant from delivery may be the conjoined twin babies, much more often called Siamese twin babies. Conjoined twin babies really are a really uncommon developing incident associated with unclear etiology. Frequency may be formerly believed to become 1 within 50, 000 to at least one within 100, 000 births. [v] The procedure through which monozygotic twin babies doesn’t completely individual however type conjoined twin babies isn’t nicely recognized. 2 contradicting hypotheses can be found to describe the actual roots of these.
Conjoining is actually caused by the actual imperfect splitting up associated with similar double embryos a few scientists declare. Other people claim that conjoined twin babies tend to be caused by embryo’s fusing back again collectively a while following their own preliminary splitting up.
The actual category associated with conjoined twin babies relies on the website from the marriage. For instance, when the 2 physiques fused in the xiphoid procedure (the expansion from the reduce the main sternum that combined with the ribs types the actual rib cage), after that all of us discuss Xiphopagus conjoined twin babies. (Which can make this kind of malformation distinctive is actually how the twin babies rarely reveal any kind of essential internal organs, aside from the actual lean meats. Which means the actual splitting up procedure might be carried out effectively — although it is usually the challenging problem towards the doctor. In the event of every other kind of conjoined twin babies the actual medical treatment in the event that pointed out results in the give up 1 double for that additional.
Conjoined twinnings possess increased spiritual, ethical, honest, as well as legalities through the background as well as extremely divisive right now inside the healthcare, paperwork as well as lawful towns.
There is just one point everyone decided till lately which conjoined (monozygotic) twin babies had been completely “identical. inch The actual XX egg cell creates woman conjoined twin babies. A good XY egg cell will man 1.
Surprising genetic-epigenetic divergences within monozygotic twin babies
Monozygotic twin babies tend to be extremely comparable. Nevertheless, there are several similarly amazing conditions which display which monozygotic twin babies don’t have to end up being “identical. inch There are many instances by which similar twin babies might have discordant phenotypes. The actual main paths include aneuploidy, X-chromosome inactivation variations, imprinting, as well as circulatory variations.
Aneuploidy is definitely an irregular quantity of chromosomes. This happens throughout cellular department once the chromosomes don’t individual correctly between your 2 tissue. Chromosome abnormalities happen within 1 associated with one hundred sixty reside births. The majority of instances of the aneuploidy leads to end of contract from the building unborn infant, however there might be instances associated with in existence delivery.
For instance, consider the problem of the egg cell fertilized with a Y-bearing semen. It’s been discovered which monozygotic twinning is actually related to greater than regular levels of aneuploidy; so it’s feasible when twinning had been to happen with the failing from the very first 2 blastomeres to stick to each other, aneuploidy may also happen. For the reason that scenario, the actual twin babies might have various chromosome matches. When the aneuploidy had been for that By chromosome, 1 double may be through man (XY or even XYY) as the additional will be woman (XO). This kind of male/female “identical twins” may be discovered. These types of twin babies will be thought dizygotic, once they really experienced came from monozygotically.
Between your ideas associated with monozygous twin babies as well as dizygous twin babies is actually the thought of polar entire body twin babies. Within instances associated with Polar entire body twin babies 1 semen is actually considered to fertilize the actual egg cell, whilst an additional semen is actually considered to fertilize the polar entire body.
Monozygotic twin babies tend to be hardly ever completely “identical” statements Geoffrey Machin within their amazing research. “There tend to be various kinds of genetic-epigenetic as well as prenatal environment post-zygotic systems which trigger discordance inside this kind of twin babies sets. A few of these system — flaming through heterokaryotypia (aneuploidy) in order to skewed By chromosoma inactivation — could cause severe discordance. Since the entrenched misunderstanding which monozygotic twin babies tend to be necesserely similar, numerous double sets incorrectly specified because dyzigotic. This particular simplified look at continues to be the foundation for many mother and father as well as healthcare experts nevertheless it is actually continuously becoming eroded through current refinements within our knowledge of the actual systems which alter gene framework as well as phrase throughout meiozis as well as mitozis.
A few of these divergences happen embryonic originate tissue right after zygosis possibly together with occasions which underlie dedication as well as difference associated with axes, internal organs as well as tissue throughout embryogenesis. inch
For instance a set of monozygotic twin babies along with discordant female-male phenotype each possess fouthy-six, XY karyotype with no mutation had been present in the actual SRY conserved design. (SRY, Sex-determining area B is really a sex-determining gene about the B chromosome. ) The actual man experienced combined gonadal dysgenesis, the feminine experienced real gonadal dysgenesis. [vi].
Even though discordant karyotypes tend to be recognized within similar twin babies, instances including variations within intercourse phenotype tend to be uncommon. The writer analyzed similar twin babies using the fouthy-six, XY karyotype — the man along with combined gonadal dysgenesis along with a woman along with “pure” gonadal dysgenesis. Monozygosity had been pointed out through brief conjunction replicate polymorphism evaluation. These types of findings might be related to (i) mutation as well as mosaicism including “downstream” sex-determining loci, (ii) adjustable penetrance associated with genetics this kind of asDSS/NR0B1, replication which may interrupt the actual male-determining path, or even (iii) event associated with cryptic forty five, By gonadal cellular outlines.
See, the one thing everyone decided regarding conjoined twin babies right now may be overthrown.
Prior to all of us create a additional improvement associated with setting up the building blocks in our concept let’s secede in the monozygotic twin babies as well as review the current conceiving upon intercourse.
The term “sex” or even “gender”
The term “sex” initially describes simply the actual department from the people in to 2 camps: women as well as guys. Each and every person goes in order to among the 2 genders. Nevertheless, in some instances, it may be very hard to find out regardless of whether a specific person is actually woman or even man. To have an precise dedication associated with intercourse, you have to tell apart in between a minimum of 7 elements, as well as all these elements might have atypical conditions:
1. Chromosomal intercourse or even hereditary intercourse based on the actual existence from the XX (female) or even the actual XY (male) genotype within somatic tissue (regardless in order to phenotypic manifestations).
two. Gonadal intercourse based on the actual gonadal cells existing (ovarian or even testicular).
3. Hormonal intercourse (or phenotypic intercourse, the actual phenotypic manifestations associated with intercourse based on endocrine affects.
four. Inner item reproductive system buildings
5. Exterior intercourse internal organs (or morphological intercourse based on the actual morphology from the exterior genitals).
6. Intercourse associated with task or even showing
7. Lovemaking Self-identification
The actual 7 elements identifying an individual’s intercourse — within each their own standard as well as atypical variants — tend to be impartial of every additional. Consequently, within person instances, you will find a lot of feasible combos. Therefore, within people, “sex” happens to be the complicated trend along with natural, mental, as well as interpersonal elements. [vii]
Right now let us to the unique topic. The following query
Can there be any kind of opportunity which divided conjoined monozygotic twin babies is actually competent to grow?
Upon very uncommon events, an authentic XXY zygote might type monozygotic boy-girl twin babies through shedding the actual XY chromosomes for just one double and also the additional XO chromosome for that additional or even for whatever reason, following the zygote divides; 1 double manages to lose the B chromosome as well as evolves like a woman. (It’s very uncommon; under 10 instances happen to be verified. ) The feminine double will be suffering from Turner’s affliction.
Turner’s affliction is really a intercourse chromosomal aberration present in around 1 within 2000-2500 reside delivered ladies. The most typical karyotype is actually monosomy, having a total lack of 1 intercourse chromosome (45, X). This can be found in 40-50% associated with Turner’s affliction. Mosaicism happens within 30-40% such as (45, X/46, XX) having a regular cellular collection.
Infertility brought on by ovarian failing is really a attribute function within Turner affliction. Natural pregnancy are noticed within 2-5% of those ladies, or more in order to 30% possess a minimum of a few pubertal improvement, showing the actual existence associated with hair follicles within their ovaries within teenage years. Teenage ladies along with Turner’s affliction nevertheless possess hair follicles within their ovarian cortical cells boosts the chance associated with long term male fertility. [viii]
See, there’s been this type of beast because conjoined, monozygotic, boy-girl twin babies. Furthermore, there’s been an opportunity how the woman nevertheless offers hair follicles boosts the chance associated with long term male fertility. Nevertheless, due to the likelihood from the phenomena is really vanishingly little, within the common public’s thoughts this life among the natural impossibilities. Also it precisely is actually that provides Eve’s situation through fantasy in order to actuality.
The actual splitting up surgical treatment
The actual splitting up surgical treatment associated with conjoined twin babies is among the main problems associated with any kind of professional groups. The actual treatment generally is better postponed before twin babies tend to be fairly older — six-twelve several weeks old. Enhanced current success has become the derive from the actual accessibility to much more precise image resolution research as well as improved (1) anesthetic as well as (2) surgical methods as well as (3) instant renovation utilizing associated with pores and skin expanders as well as prosthetic nylon uppers or even autologous cells in order to close-up the actual injury. The actual actions from the splitting up surgical treatment reported from the healthcare book over shockingly looks like towards the explanation associated with Adam’s “biblical” surgical treatment depending on Genesis two: twenty one. And also the Head of the family Lord triggered the (1) heavy rest in order to drop on Adam; even though he or she rested, He or she (2) required part of their aspect as well as (3) shut in the skin rather thereof. inch (Genesis, two: 21KJV)
Shut in the skin rather thereof or even shut in the location along with skin
The important thing term right here the actual Hebrew “tachath” meaning “instead of”. The actual KJV and also the ASV(American Regular Version) would be the just 2 translations designed to use the word associated with “closed in the skin rather thereof”. The actual Increased Holy bible for instance complements the actual phrase associated with “closed in the [place with] flesh”. Both rather than and also the location imply the actual deficiency (i. at the. wound) surfaced in the splitting up surgical treatment. (They couldn’t make reference to rib, simply because changing the rib along with skin doesn’t help to make any kind of feeling concerning any type of medical treatment. )
As the explanation from the very first 2 actions towards the process nearly suits in order to each and every surgical treatment achieved on the body, the 3rd action “closed in the location along with flesh” limits the horizon to some really thin part of the medical actions specifically towards the reconstructive methods.
Right now it’s time for you to uncover the concept that obviously requires additional evidence because adhere to quickly. Nevertheless thinking about just about all information all of us offered to date it may be thought how the most well-known human being few was created because conjoined twin babies. These were divided as well as elevated very carefully as well as next these were reunited in order to grow.
When the situation statement from the conjoined Adam as well as Event might have already been obtainable, we’d study: “Fully created conjoined twin babies along with various chromosomal, gonadal, morphological as well as phenotypical genders, became a member of in the top upper body in the clavicle towards the sternum. You will find individual mind, top braches. Genitalia within each twin babies subjected. Twin babies along with discordant female-male phenotype which offers fouthy-six, XY and also the additional fouthy-six XO karyotype. (An unique XXY zygote created monozygotic boy-girl twin babies through shedding the actual XY chromosomes for just one double and also the additional XO chromosome for that additional or even for whatever reason, following the zygote divides, 1 double dropped the B chromosome as well as created like a woman along with Turner’s affliction. inch
The following secret
Gen. two: twenty two states, “And the actual rib (side), that Jehovah Lord experienced obtained from the person, created (banah) he or she a female, as well as introduced the woman’s towards the man” (American Regular Version). This particular interpretation makes the actual Hebrew action-word banah because produced in British. It’s a fascinating get from the feasible which means from the globe banah in the event that all of us think about the number of occasions the actual Hebrew term happens within the Holy bible (376) as well as becoming converted within the Sanctioned Edition (KJV) because — construct (340), develop (14), contractor (10), created (3), constructed once again, restore (2), setup (2), possess children(1), acquire children(1), certainly (1).
Right now consider the subsequent passage: (Gen. sixteen: 2) “And Sarai stated on to Abram, See right now, god, the father hath controlled me personally through showing: We hope thee, use on to my personal house maid; it might be which i might acquire kids (banah) through the woman’s. [ix] In other words there’s a feasible which means in our passage such as this “And along side it, that Jehovah Lord experienced obtained from the person, grew up because he might end up being acquire kids as well as introduced the woman’s towards the man”.
An additional meaning associated with ‘God created him or her the woman’: Ur. Hisda mentioned: This particular shows how the Holy 1, fortunate end up being He or she, constructed Event within the form of the storehouse. Like a storehouse is created broad beneath as well as thin over in order that it might retain the create, therefore had been the actual tummy of the lady created broad beneath as well as thin over in order that it might retain the embryo. [x] That’s therefore accurate, however the banah pertains a lot more complex procedure Event had been posted.
“Women along with Turner’s affliction ought to be very carefully adopted all through existence. Growth hormones treatment ought to be began from grow older 2-5 many years. Hormone alternative treatment for that improvement associated with regular woman lovemaking features ought to be began from grow older 12-15 many years as well as ongoing with regard to the long run to avoid coronary artery illness as well as brittle bones. Nearly all women along with Turner’s affliction possess ovarian dysgenesis; consequently, they’re usually infertile, as well as within really uncommon instances possess natural menses then earlier menopause.
Just 2% (according additional resources 2-5%) from the ladies possess organic pregnancies” based on Abir Ur. (Department associated with Obstetrics as well as Gynecology, RabinMedicalCenter)
Event experienced. Your woman introduced to the globe Cain as well as Abel.
Males Tend to be through Mars. Ladies Tend to be through Venus.
Within the name from the significantly well-liked guide through Steve Grey, the actual author claims the idea which women and men tend to be because various because creatures through additional exoplanets. In the event that all of us demand for this picture, we ought to place it by doing this: Males tend to be going to Mars, Ladies in order to Venus.
The truth is how the various sexes in our competition, man as well as woman descends from single becoming, a good unusual and incredibly uncommon beast, as well as conjoined twin babies. Whilst 1 double offered the actual options that come with man sex (XY chromosomal intercourse, the actual gonadal cells is actually testicular, exterior man intercourse internal organs, and so on. ), the actual other peoples karyotype as well as phenotype look like those that ladies along with Turner-syndrome possess. Ever since then from the delivery in our conjoined twin babies, the actual man and also the woman children of the possess diverged with regard to decades as well as decades because of the lot of natural, mental, as well as interpersonal affects.
Numerous students possess noticed the concept how the very first guy as well as lady had been became a member of collectively just one androgynous (i. at the. getting the features or even character associated with each man as well as woman or even nor particularly womanly neither masculine) beast is actually legally advised through the biblical textual content by itself.
Rabbinic resources declare that the very first Guy, Adam had been the dual-entity who had been after that divided possibly in between entrance as well as back again. Ur. Jeremiah w. Eleazar stated: The very first guy experienced 2 complete encounters, with regard to it is stated within Bible: Thou hast formed me personally at the rear of as well as prior to (Psalm 139: 5).
Rosehill Posting 2012 Just about all privileges set aside
[i] dorshav. typepad. com
[ii] Copyright laws 1996 through David Simpson Written by the actual Biblical Investigation Basis 629 Lexington Street, Sapulpa, OKAY 74066
[iii] barakatgallery. com
[iv] Ellie Utes. D., Jo DS, Jang Nited kingdom B, Cho Utes D. 2007. Very uncommon situation associated with cephalothoracopagus seen as a variations associated with exterior genitalia, 28: 1151-1153. 1596 UNITED STATES DIARY ASSOCIATED WITH HEALTHCARE INHERITED GENES
[v] The multicenter globally investigation such as the biggest test associated with CT actually analyzed. An overall total associated with 383 very carefully examined models associated with CT from twenty six, 138, 837 births documented through twenty one Clearinghouse Monitoring Applications (SP) had been contained in the evaluation. Complete frequency had been 1. forty seven for each 100, 000 births (95% CI: 1. 32-1. 62). Conjoined twin babies: An international collaborative epidemiological research from the Worldwide Clearinghouse with regard to Delivery Flaws Monitoring as well as Investigation. United states Diary associated with Healthcare Inherited genes Component D: Workshops within Healthcare Inherited genes, 157: 274-287.
[vi] Somkuti whatsoever 2000
[vii] http: //www2. hu-berlin. de/sexology/ECE1/index1. htm
[viii] (J Clin Endocrinol Metab 87: 3618-3623, 2002 Hair follicles Are simply within the Ovaries associated with Teenage Ladies along with Turner’s Affliction OUTI HOVATTA).
[ix] Azure Notice Holy bible. “Dictionary as well as Term Look for ‘”be which i might acquire children”‘ within the KJV”. Azure Notice Holy bible. 1996-2012. fourteen Annual percentage rates 2012. http: //www. blueletterbible. org/search/translationResults. cfm?
[x] Eruvin 18b